Yeargain Foot & Ankle

Hammer Toe vs. Bunion: Symptoms and Solutions

It’s easy to overlook the value of foot health until you’ve experienced the excruciating symptoms of a hammer toe. Unfortunately, some people mistake it for a bunion, which is also a painful condition. Knowing the difference between a hammer toe vs. bunion will help find relief and lasting solutions for these common foot problems.

Hammer Toe vs. Bunion – What’s the Difference?

A hammer toe (also spelled as hammertoe) is different from a bunion. However, it’s important to keep in mind that if you leave a bunion untreated for a while, it can lead to other foot problems such as calluses, hammer toes, and corns. These conditions can make walking difficult, let alone wearing your favorite shoes.

hammer toe vs bunion

So, hammer toe vs. bunion – what are the symptoms to watch out for?

A hammer toe is classified as a contracture deformity, which can occur in one or, in some instances, on both joints of your toes. It usually occurs on the second to fourth (sometimes the fifth) toes of your feet. When you develop this deformity, your toe is bent at an angle, making it look like a hammer, hence the name.

On the other hand, a bunion is also known as a Hallux Valgus. It looks like a bump that forms at the joint of your big toe. It’s a prominent bony feature on the side of your foot, and it can also be painful. It occurs when the joints on your big toe get misaligned.

This mal-alignment causes your big toe joints to move towards your other smaller toes, thus becoming a potential cause for developing a hammer toe. In many instances, when patients have both a hammer toe and a bunion, they usually opt to have both conditions corrected at the same time.

Understanding the Causes

Other than having an untreated bunion over time, some causes lead to the formation of hammer toes. For example, certain factors like the type of shoes you wear, abnormal balance or instability in the toe muscles, and sometimes trauma can cause an individual to develop hammer toes.

  • Muscle/Tendon Imbalance

Experts consider a muscle or tendon imbalance in the toes the most common cause of this foot deformity. When there’s an imbalance in the tendons, ligaments and muscles in your toes, it causes contractures or bending. Once bent, mechanical and neurological changes occur in the foot.

It causes the toes to remain in a bent position for a long time and can prevent the toe from straightening out. All the muscles in the human body work in pairs, and an imbalance can cause this deformity.

  • Trauma

Foot injuries can also lead to hammer toes. If your toes get fractured and they are left untreated, it can lead to this condition over time.

  • Improper Fitting Shoes

Believe it or not, when you wear shoes that are either too small or fit your feet too tightly, it can contribute to the formation of a hammer toe. If your toes are already misaligned, to begin with, then wearing shoes that don’t fit your feet properly can further aggravate this condition.

Here’s a bit of a warning for people who like to wear wedges or high-heeled shoes: these shoes tend to force the toes into a rather cramped position. They make your feet push the toes down against the shoe. It creates a lot of pressure making the toes bend, which can cause this deformity.

Hammer Toe Risk Factors

There are also certain risk factors contributing to the formation of this foot problem. For example, your toe length, sex, age and certain diseases can increase your risk for developing it.

  1. Toe Length: If your second toe is noticeably longer than your big toe, then you’re at a higher risk of developing a hammer toe there.
  2. Sex: Women are usually at a higher risk of developing this deformity than men.
  3. Age: The risk for developing hammertoes increases with a person’s age.
  4. Disease: Diabetes and arthritis can make one more prone to developing a hammer toe and other foot deformities.
  5. Genetics: You may also inherit the tendency to get hammer toes from your genetics.

Yeargain Foot & Ankle’s Hammer Toe Treatment Plan

Here at Yeargain Foot & Ankle, our team will take the time to evaluate your condition carefully. We work towards determining the cause of your hammer toe. We don’t recommend surgery immediately, and we always consider the least invasive and most conservative options first.
We understand that each patient is different, which is why we come up with a unique treatment plan for you. The treatment will also be based on the severity of the deformity. Some of the non-surgical solutions that can be considered are:

  • Changing footwear: We don’t recommend wearing shoes that have heels higher than two inches. We’ll also recommend avoiding narrow or tight shoes. You should wear shoes that have a wider toe space.
  • Custom orthotics: We offer custom 3D scanned orthotics to our clients to fit different shoes for daily wear or special occasions and athletics. These can help with tendon and muscle imbalances in your feet.
  • Splinting/strapping: These are medical techniques that help with toe realignment.
  • Exercises: Our staff will also help you with exercises that help stretch and strengthen foot muscles. Examples of these are towel curls, calf stretches, and weight-bearing exercises.
  • Medications: Our doctors can also prescribe Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) to treat the pain and inflammation. We can also use corticosteroid injections if necessary.

Surgical Management

In some cases, surgery may be warranted to treat a patient. It’s usually a last resort often used for hammer toes that have become too rigid and extremely painful. At Yeargain Foot & Ankle, we typically recommend surgery after all non-surgical treatments have been considered.

This procedure is quite effective, with a high success rate. It’s also a straightforward procedure, which can correct and straighten hammer toes. Your physician will discuss the possible treatments with you, which may include joint fusion, tendon lengthening, and tendon transfers. The severity of the deformity will often dictate which procedures will be performed for you.

Get Relief…
Right Where You Work

If you work in Downtown Dallas you know the challenge of working a full day and then finding time for a podiatry appointment. That’s why we have two clinics located in the downtown area. Schedule your appointment and customized treatment plan right where you work. We will get you in, get you relief, and get you back to active living.

Yeargain Foot & Ankle

3801 Gaston Ave #330
Dallas, TX 75246
(972) 853-4886

Get Directions

Oak Cliff/Methodist Hospital
1411 N Beckley Ave. Suite 456
Dallas, TX 75203
Pavilion III at Methodist Hospital
(972) 845-4970

Get Directions


Monday 9am – 5pm
Tuesday 9am – 5pm
Wednesday 9am – 5pm
Thursday 9am – 5pm
Friday 9am – 1pm

For Appointments
Call or Text: (972) 853-4886

YF&A - Our Approach And Promise
Serving Downtown Dallas Since 2014

  • Amazing care for all clients
  • Feel good AND look good!
  • Personable and professional
  • Sports medicine podiatry experts
  • Trained in plastics (muscular & skeletal work with great aesthetics)
  • Easy to talk to and understand
  • Located for urban workers
  • Comfortable office environment
  • Available, accessible, convenient
  • Network for quality referrals (for complex reconstructive surgery if needed)

Book Appointment

"*" indicates required fields

First Name
Last Name
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.